Mentoring is often discussed in general terms, but what does it actually look like in practice?
As part of our spotlight on the Phil Tindall Memorial Medal, which recognises outstanding mentors in the civil engineering industry, we spoke to Paul Pankhurst, the most recent recipient of the award, about his approach.
Rather than a formal framework, his perspective is shaped by experience and what has worked in practice over time. We are sharing his reflections and top tips below.
Mentoring is often discussed in general terms, but what does it actually look like in practice?
As part of our spotlight on the Phil Tindall Memorial Medal, which recognises outstanding mentors in the civil engineering industry, we spoke to Paul Pankhurst, the most recent recipient of the award, about his approach.
Rather than a formal framework, his perspective is shaped by experience and what has worked in practice over time. We are sharing his reflections and top tips below.
1. Let mentoring develop naturally over time
One of the clearest themes was that undertaking mentoring rarely starts off as a deliberate decision.
It tends to build naturally and informally as people progress in their careers, perhaps becoming more formal over time. Early on, it might involve supporting students or graduates. Over time, it can extend to more senior colleagues. The context changes, but the core idea stays the same, which is helping others move forward and realise opportunity.
2. Adapt your approach to the individual
There is no single way to mentor effectively.
Paul reflected that each person needs something different, and that can change depending on where they are in their career. A rigid structure can sometimes get in the way and what matters more is being able to respond to the individual and adjust the approach as needed.
It also means recognising when someone would benefit from other perspectives. Encouraging people to seek out more than one mentor can be just as important as the mentoring itself.
3. Give people space to learn from experience
Mentoring is not about having all the answers. A large part of it is creating the space for people to try things for themselves. That includes allowing things to go wrong on occasion, as long as there is support in place to help them recover and learn from it.
4. Take a long-term view
Mentoring works over time rather than through one-off conversations. The aim is not to solve a single problem, but to help someone develop more broadly. In many cases, the impact only becomes clear years later.
One of the most rewarding aspects is seeing people who have been mentored go on to support others in the same way.
5. Help people find the right balance
A useful way to think about mentoring is in terms of balance.
The goal is to help people reach a point where they feel challenged in their work, supported by those around them, and engaged in what they are doing. When that balance is in place, people are more likely to progress and stay motivated.
6. Recognise and celebrate great mentors
The Phil Tindall Memorial Medal highlights individuals who make a meaningful difference to others’ careers, often without seeking recognition.
Nominations for this year’s award will open in November.
If there is someone who consistently supports and develops those around them, this is an opportunity to recognise their contribution to the profession.
Nominations for this year’s award will open in November.
If there is someone who consistently supports and develops those around them, this is an opportunity to recognise their contribution to the profession.
